On anxiety, the hope of new lives and bad behaviour in public life

Peer over the edge of your doubts into a land of uncertainty and clamour. The loud screech of fear that arises whenever we find ourselves prey to anxiety.

Without understanding the cause of whatever ails us, we can’t readily work out what to do with the problem, the issues, the experiences, the forces behind it. The propulsive forces driving it. In other words, if you don’t start asking the why of it, it’s not so easy to get to the how.

October and November are birthday season in my life, at least seven from my immediate family have their birthdays this month. With this comes celebration and a deep sense of the passage of time. This time last year the youngest of our grandchildren arrived six weeks early. 

She’s still tiny but thriving in ways I might never have dreamed possible. A powerhouse of joy and spirit. She has a magical smile that washes away all pain. Along with her six-month-older cousin who came at the appointed time into a world of family and noise.

He too is a delightful presence, just learning to walk and talk; he offers reassurance at a time when those who have not yet entered the cut and thrust of full-on toddlerhood into childhood and the rest, enter.

A one-year-old child is a joy. 

This against the current world order, which seems extraordinarily divided and in many places hostile. Driven by the free-range hostilities of social media, the trolls and endless attacks on our governmental representatives which can feel like a bunch of adolescents decrying their parents for not doing a better job. Only these teenagers have guns, knives, and evil intent. They want to hurt and not only with words.

And the parental governmental representative must look to themselves as well to reflect on the way they relate to one another because they too model bad behaviour and the rest follow.

Children tend to model themselves on their parents until they begin to rebel, and then they can go in opposite directions. To rebel and define themselves differntly from thise who reared them.

Sometimes I try to remember what it was like when I was tiny and firmly convinced that the things the nuns taught, running parallels with my mother’s religious convictions, were true. That there was this person high in the sky called God who looked over us. Who was kind enough but not when we sinned. 

When we sinned, he turned into a person of fury and rage, and we needed to repent pronto or we would be cast into the fires of hell, at least in our minds, well ahead of our death, and then all hope would be lost. 

All hope rested in remaining a good person, eschewing all signs of hatred and dishonesty. An unselfish person who thought only of the needs of others, who worked hard at school, who helped around the house, kept a tidy room and mind and did not complain too heartily at mealtimes when our mother fed us rabbit – which I disliked immensely so caught up in images of creatures with long ears – and called it chicken. 

Not that I did not despair for the chooks that ran around in movies or their tiny chickens, but I learned the art of compartmentalisation early. The way it’s possible to put one fact into a drawer over in one corner and keep it separate from the set of drawers on the other side of the room. Not to associate the white meat we ate at dinner with the feathered creatures in the barnyard.

But I could not so easily disconnect those elements in my mind termed impure thoughts. The thoughts that cropped up in relation to my own corporeal form. To have a body was a bother. It meant you had feelings under your skin between your bones and your flesh, which you did not always understand but which needed reining in. It meant you needed to control your hunger for food, for objects and for attention. You needed to tell yourself you could do without.

Everything seemed such a mystery when I was small; the way things worked made little sense, especially the way the grown-ups operated. The unpredictability of my father’s moods, his thick accent heavy with a type of anger which seemed unanchored to anything but to everything around him. 

He rarely smiled, and when he did, it seemed as if his face was cracking in some porcelain-like, bizarre way that seemed sinister rather than softening. While my mother hid her rage behind a veneer of good cheer and kindness. But when she was angry her eyes glazed over as if she had suddenly decided I no longer existed within her orbit. A dust mote to be wiped away. A dead leaf to be trod on. My father’s unbridled rage was in some ways easier to deal with than my mother’s hidden fury. And because her love seemed the loudest, her displeasure cut deepest.

Skimming the surface of my memories, I cannot come to any conclusions here. I do not know the causes of my melancholy today beyond a sense that all is not well in my world despite the presence of the new little people in our midst. 

If only for me it was not so. If only I could regain something of my childlike determination to do the right thing. Or shift all the unwanted motions into one drawer in an unused room of my house and let only the good senses in, but it goes against the grain to follow in my mother’s footsteps. She was a master at this. 

And acknowledge all the mixed feelings of life. Like the fact my lovely hairdresser is tilting to the right; and as much as I try to speak the language of empathy and concern for, say migrants which I believe is essential – both of us coming from migrant stock – it’s not one bit easy to convince him of his privilege when he is convinced otherwise.

And why bother. Better to stay stumm and get on with the business of a badly needed haircut, my hair like an over-plumped bird’s nest on my head and not bother with the small talk that is the usual fare of a trip to the hairdressers. But I have been visiting this man for some three decades, and over time you get to know one another well. it’s hard, as hard as it is in families, to ignore each other’s politics. 

But next time I see him, I shall try.

Softening the blow

Siblings, Galit Atlas writes ‘are our first peers, rivals, witnesses and companions, a source of love, envy, compassion and identification. So much of competitiveness and envy is shaped by our experience of siblings.’ And as other psychoanalytic folks write, it’s a horizontal influence rather than the one most often explored, the vertical influence of parents, from top down.

When I was small I felt no great need for friends outside of my family. My siblings were my friends, especially those closest in age, my two slightly older brothers and my younger sisters. My older sister led the way, and the two eldest brothers belonged to the realm of adults and therefore counted less, except as further authority figures who came and went. While the two below them and the one below me were my best friends. 

We spent hours, weeks, months in one another’s company and their presence softened the blows of all the abuse we copped at the hands of our father.

I well remember the story of the babes in the wood, two children orphaned and left to fend for themselves. Together they wandered lost through a forest, and exhausted, stopped at the base of a tree where they died. Soon a Robin redbreast covered them in leaves. But no, as Atlas writes, ‘Abuse in families separates siblings into what she describes as ‘a solitary survival strategy, while aggression in the family can be enacted among the children.’ 

Juliet Mithell in her turn writes about the law of the mother, a law that ensures siblings do not kill one another, but as each new baby arrives, supplanting the one before, the child enduring the arrival of a sibling must learn the difference between the same and other. Before the new baby comes along there is a sense this baby will be the same as me.  But after the baby is born, comes the realisation, this baby is other than me. The toddler, or older child whatever age, will need to find ways of coping with the arrival of this rival and it’s their mother’s awareness of the pain of this and her efforts to help them negotiate the new order that makes all the difference.

I well remember the jealousy I felt towards my immediately younger sister. The way I considered her so much more beautiful than me. It rankled. My mother told the story of how walking along with my sister in her pram people stopped to admire the baby while, toddling alongside, I attracted none of their admiration. 

Years later, she told me how she tried to soften the blow by alerting admirers to me but it made little difference. I continued in my jealousy towards my beautiful sister who looked more like our dark-haired movie star mother, at least in her youth, while I took after my father with my long face, fair hair and less well-balanced features. 

Small things like this matter when you’re little. The understanding I gained here from my analyst stays with me still. 

She pointed out how my mother found it difficult to tolerate the competition and rivalry between us siblings. When we argued and fought, she fell in a heap, weeping. ‘How can you behave so?’ She was the eldest of her tribe of seven, followed by five brothers and only one sister, a twin six years younger. 

Atlas describes the eldest, like my mother, as the ‘melancholic child’, one who has endured early loss repeated again and again depending on the number of children.

In any case, when I told Mrs Milanova about my jealousy towards my sister and my mother’s disapproval of such feelings, she suggested it was not helpful to disapprove of any uncomfortable feelings. 

Feelings such as jealousy need understanding. It’s a painful feeling, and let’s face it, it’s universal for us all at various times in our lives. If you then get the message from your parents that there’s something wrong with you for feeling this way, then the feeling is ten times worse.  And you feel bad for feeling it in the first place. 

You cannot help a feeling. Feelings come on us unbidden. But it helps to interrogate them first before responding rather than simply reacting.

And it’s not easy.